v2.07.100 SHLV100 - Réponse harmonique d’un cylindre creux en déformations planes#

Résumé:

Ce test tridimensionnel axisymétrique permet de valider les calculs des matrices de rigidité, de masse et des vecteurs de pression sur tous les éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) et \(\mathrm{2D}\) déformations planes et axisymétriques (10 modélisations).

Les déplacements sont imposés :

  • soit par degrés de liberté,

  • soit par face d’élément.

Pour les quatre modélisations 3D, les pressions appliquées sont fournies avec le signe moins, car les faces d’éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) sont mal orientés dans les fichiers de maillage utilisés.

Solution de référence#

Méthode de calcul utilisée pour la solution de référence#

../../../../_images/Object_713.svg

Les constantes \(A\) et \(B\) sont calculées en résolvant le système linéaire obtenu en écrivant :

\({\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}(a)=-p\) \({\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}(b)=0\)

On obtient :

Pour \(r=0.1\)

\({u}_{r}=7.3398{10}^{-3}\)

Pour \(r=0.2\)

\({u}_{r}=4.6816{10}^{-3}\)

\({\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}=-1\)

\({\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}=0.\)

\({\sigma}_{\theta \theta }=1.6685\)

\({\sigma}_{\theta \theta }=0.66738\)

\({\sigma}_{zz}=0.20055\)

\({\sigma}_{zz}=0.20031\)

Passage dans le système d’axes cartésiens :

\(\begin{array}{ccc}{\sigma}_{xx}& =& {\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}{\cos}^{2}\theta +{\sigma}_{\theta \theta }{\sin}^{2}\theta -2{\sigma}_{r\theta }\sin\theta \cos\theta \\ {\sigma}_{yy}& =& {\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}{\sin}^{2}\theta +{\sigma}_{\theta \theta }{\cos}^{2}\theta +2{\sigma}_{r\theta }\sin\theta \cos\theta \\ {\sigma}_{xy}& =& {\sigma}_{\mathrm{rr}}\sin\theta \cos\theta -{\sigma}_{\theta \theta }\sin\theta \cos\theta -2{\sigma}_{r\theta }({\cos}^{2}\theta -{\sin}^{2}\theta )\end{array}\)

avec :

\(\theta =0°\) aux points \(A\) et \(B\)

\(\theta =22.5°\) aux points \(C\) et \(D\)

\(\theta =45°\) aux points \(E\) et \(F\)

Résultats de référence#

Déplacements \((u,v)\) et contraintes

../../../../_images/Object_1215.svg

aux points \(A,B,C,D,E,F\) .

Incertitude sur la solution#

Précision du calcul des Fonctions de Bessel.

Références bibliographiques#

    1. BONNET : Méthodes des équations intégrales régularisées en élastodynamique- Bulletin de la DER - Série C - N°1/2 - (1987).

  1. ERINGEN - SUHUBI - Elastodynamics, Vol.2 : linear theory Academic Press (1975).

Modélisation A#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) (PENTA6 et HEXA8) (issu du maillage \(\mathrm{2D}\) ci-dessous).

../../../../_images/1000595A00001C6C0000136E1FC7E94653094F79.svg

suivant l’axe \(Z\) : 2 couches d’éléments épaisseur totale : 0.01

Conditions limites :

DDL_IMPO:

( Tout:’oui’

Dz: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{AB}\)

( Group_no:BordAB

Dy: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:FaceEF

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur la face \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:FaceAE

Pres: -1. )

Noms des nœuds :

A=No1

B=No119

C=No36

D=No166

E=No41

F=No171

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 513

Nombre de mailles et types : 400 PENTA6100 HEXA840 QUAD4

Remarques#

La pression a un signe négatif (au lieu de positif) car les faces des éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) sont mal orientées.

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_1318.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1416.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1515.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1614.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1712.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1812.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 1.6685 0.20055 0.

7.3243 10–3

eps –0.8789 1.6241 0.2235 –0.0922

–0.21

– 12.1 –2.66 11.75 –

10–2

0.2

0.2

C

../../../../_images/Object_1915.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2010.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2111.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2212.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2314.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2414.svg
6.78109 10–3

2.80882 10–3 –0.60921 1.27771 0.20055 –0.94346

6.7670 10–3

2.8012 10–3 –0.5121 1.3300 0.2454 –0.8567

–0.21

–0.27 15.94 4.09 22.39 9.20

10–2

0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3

E

../../../../_images/Object_2514.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2613.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2712.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2810.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2911.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3013.svg
5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 –1.33425

5.1784 10–3

5.1784 10–3 0.4319 0.5315 0.289 –1.269

–0.22

–0.22 29.23 59.04 44.50 4.87

10–2

0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6

B

../../../../_images/Object_3112.svg ../../../../_images/Object_329.svg ../../../../_images/Object_331.svg ../../../../_images/Object_342.svg ../../../../_images/Object_351.svg ../../../../_images/Object_363.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.66738 0.20021 0.

4.6641 10–3

eps –0.0132 0.6724 0.1977 0.0219

–0.16

– – 0.75 –1.25 –

10–2

2.10–2 – –

D

../../../../_images/Object_375.svg ../../../../_images/Object_385.svg ../../../../_images/Object_392.svg ../../../../_images/Object_402.svg ../../../../_images/Object_413.svg ../../../../_images/Object_421.svg
4.32523 10–3

1.79157 10–3 0.09774 0.56964 0.20021 –0.23595

4.3084 10–3

1.7854 10–3 0.0739 0.5728 0.1941 –0.2348

–0.39

–0.34 –24.39 0.56 –3.05 0.49

10–2

0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3

F

../../../../_images/Object_431.svg ../../../../_images/Object_442.svg ../../../../_images/Object_451.svg ../../../../_images/Object_461.svg ../../../../_images/Object_471.svg ../../../../_images/Object_482.svg
3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 –0.33369

3.2974 10–3

3.2974 10–3 0.2977 0.3245 0.1866 –0.3415

–0.39

–0.39 –10.78 2.75 –6.80 –2.34

10–2

0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

Remarques#

Le maillage est insuffisant pour des éléments linéaires.

Modélisation B#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) (PENTA15 et HEXA20) (issu du maillage \(\mathrm{2D}\) ci-dessous).

../../../../_images/1000583A00002922000014E1F3BBD75A2BB4E5F3.svg

suivant l’axe \(Z\) : 2 couches d’éléments épaisseur totale : 0.01

Conditions limites :

DDL_IMPO:

( Tout:’oui’

Dz: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{AB}\)

( Group_no:BordAB

Dx: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:FaceEF

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur la face \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:FaceAE

Pres: -1. )

Noms des nœuds :

A=No2

B=No361

C=No121

D=No584

E=No155

F=No503

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 2115

Nombre de mailles et types : 400 PENTA15100 HEXA2040 QUAD8

Remarques#

La pression a un signe négatif (au lieu de positif) car les faces des éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) sont mal orientées.

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_491.svg ../../../../_images/Object_501.svg ../../../../_images/Object_512.svg ../../../../_images/Object_522.svg ../../../../_images/Object_531.svg ../../../../_images/Object_541.svg
  1. 7.3398 10–3 1.6685 –1. 0.20055 0.

eps

7.3326 10–3 1.6669 –0.9959 0.2013 3.3234 10–3

–0.10 –0.09 0.41 0.37 –

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

C

../../../../_images/Object_551.svg ../../../../_images/Object_561.svg ../../../../_images/Object_571.svg ../../../../_images/Object_583.svg ../../../../_images/Object_591.svg ../../../../_images/Object_601.svg
–2.80882 10–3

6.78109 10–3 1.27771 –0.60921 0.20055 0.94346

–2.8063 10–3

6.7745 10–3 1.278 –0.6078 0.20107 0.94027

–0.09

–0.10 0.02 0.23 0.26 0.34

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

E

../../../../_images/Object_613.svg ../../../../_images/Object_621.svg ../../../../_images/Object_631.svg ../../../../_images/Object_641.svg ../../../../_images/Object_651.svg ../../../../_images/Object_661.svg
–5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 1.33425

–5.1851 10–3

5.1851 10–3 0.3346 0.3340 0.2006 1.331

–0.09

–0.10 0.10 –0.07 0.02 –0.24

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

B

../../../../_images/Object_672.svg ../../../../_images/Object_684.svg ../../../../_images/Object_694.svg ../../../../_images/Object_70.svg ../../../../_images/Object_714.svg ../../../../_images/Object_721.svg
  1. 4.6716 10–3 0.66738 0. 0.20021 0.

eps

4.6682 10–3 0.6675 3.2779 10–4 0.2003 –5.0918 10–4

–0.07 0.02 – 0.04 –

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_731.svg ../../../../_images/Object_742.svg ../../../../_images/Object_751.svg ../../../../_images/Object_762.svg ../../../../_images/Object_774.svg ../../../../_images/Object_782.svg
–1.79157 10–3

4.32523 10–3 0.56964 0.09774 0.20021 0.23595

–1.7864 10–3

4.3129 10–3 0.56957 0.09803 0.20027 0.23623

–0.29

–0.29 –0.01 0.30 0.03 0.12

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

F

../../../../_images/Object_793.svg ../../../../_images/Object_804.svg ../../../../_images/Object_8110.svg ../../../../_images/Object_822.svg ../../../../_images/Object_831.svg ../../../../_images/Object_841.svg
–3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 0.33369

–3.3009 10–3

3.3009 10–3 0.3337 0.3337 0.2002 0.3339

–0.29

–0.29 –0.003 0.003 0. 0.06

10–2

10–2 10–3 10–3 10–3 10–3

Modélisation C#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments 3D (TETRA4)

suivant l’axe \(Z\) : 2 couches d’éléments épaisseur totale : 0.01

Conditions limites :

DDL_IMPO:

( Tout:’oui’

Dz: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{AB}\)

( Group_no:BordAB

Dy: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:FaceEF

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur la face \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:FaceAE

Pres: -1. )

Noms des nœuds :

A=No3

B=No7

C=No4

D=No8

E=No154

F=No156

plan \(z=0.005\)

A2=No1

B2=No5

C2=No2

D2=No6

E2=No153

F2=No155

plan \(z=0.01\)

A3=No283

B3=No285

C3=No284

D3=No286

E3=No359

F3=No360

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 423

Nombre de mailles et types : 1416 TETRA472 TRIA3

Remarques#

La pression a un signe négatif (au lieu de positif) car les faces des éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) sont mal orientées.

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_851.svg ../../../../_images/Object_862.svg ../../../../_images/Object_873.svg ../../../../_images/Object_882.svg ../../../../_images/Object_892.svg ../../../../_images/Object_903.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 1.6685 0.20055 0.

7.3331 10–3

eps –0.9000 1.6809 0.2343 0.1016

–0.10

+10.00 0.74 16.83 -

10–2

0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02

C

../../../../_images/Object_917.svg ../../../../_images/Object_924.svg ../../../../_images/Object_933.svg ../../../../_images/Object_942.svg ../../../../_images/Object_953.svg ../../../../_images/Object_962.svg
6.78109 10–3

2.80882 10–3 –0.60921 1.27771 0.20055 –0.94346

6.7783 10–3

2.8077 10–3 –0.5061 1.3184 0.2437 –0.9123

–0.04

–0.04 16.92 3.18 21.51 3.30

10–2

0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04

E

../../../../_images/Object_972.svg ../../../../_images/Object_983.svg ../../../../_images/Object_993.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1003.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1017.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1024.svg
5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 –1.33425

5.1853 10–3

5.1853 10–3 0.2888 0.4920 0.2343 –1.2905

–0.09

–0.09 –13.60 47.19 16.83 3.28

10–2

0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5

B

../../../../_images/Object_1032.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1043.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1052.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1063.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1072.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1082.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.66738 0.20021 0.

4.6634 10–3

eps 0.0146 0.6570 0.1976 –0.0159

–0.18

–1.55 –1.30 -

10–2

5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_1092.svg ../../../../_images/Object_11010.svg ../../../../_images/Object_11110.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1123.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1132.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1142.svg
4.32523 10–3

1.79157 10–3 0.09774 0.56964 0.20021 –0.23595

4.2960 10–3

1.7795 10–3 0.0824 0.5809 0.1921 –0.2378

–0.68

–0.67 –15.69 1.97 –4.05 –7.84

10–2

0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

F

../../../../_images/Object_1152.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1163.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1173.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1182.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1193.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1203.svg
3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 –0.33369

3.2976 10–3

3.2975 10–3 0.3052 0.3371 0.1921 –0.3358

–0.39

–0.39 –8.54 1.02 –4.05 –0.63

10–2

0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1

Remarques#

On note une variation (\(\text{< 0.24\%}\) ) des déplacements pour les points du plan \(z=0.005\) .

Le maillage est insuffisant pour des éléments linéaires.

Modélisation D#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments 3D (TETRA10)

suivant l’axe Z : 2 couches d’éléments épaisseur totale : 0.01

Conditions limites :

DDL_IMPO:

( Tout:’oui’

Dz: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{AB}\)

( Group_no:BordAB

Dy: 0. )

face \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:FaceEF

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur la face \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:FaceAE

Pres: -1. )

Noms des nœuds :

A=No3

B=No7

C=No4

D=No8

E=No1228

F=No230

plan z = 0.005

A2=No1

B2=No5

C2=No2

D2=No6

E2=No227

F2=No229

plan z = 0.01

A3=No420

B3=No422

C3=No421

D3=No423

E3=No573

F3=No574

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 703

Nombre de mailles et types : 356 TETRA10 36 TRIA6

Remarques#

La pression a un signe négatif (au lieu de positif) car les faces des éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) sont mal orientées.

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_1216.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1222.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1232.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1242.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1253.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1262.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 1.6685 0.20055 0.

7.3522 10–3

eps –0.9925 1.6725 0.2040 –0.0365

0.10

0.75 0.24 –1.72 -

10–2

10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2

C

../../../../_images/Object_1274.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1283.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1291.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1302.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1319.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1323.svg
6.78109 10–3

2.80882 10–3 –0.60921 1.27771 0.20055 –0.94346

6.7836 10–3

2.8099 10–3 –0.5977 1.294 0.2088 –0.9457

0.04

0.04 1.89 1.28 4.11 –0.24

10–2

10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2

E

../../../../_images/Object_1331.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1341.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1353.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1362.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1373.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1381.svg
5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 –1.33425

5.1988 10–3

5.1988 10–3 0.3035 0.3766 0.2040 –1.332

0.17

0.17 –9.20 12.67 1.72 0.17

10–2

10–2 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15

B

../../../../_images/Object_1393.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1401.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1417.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1422.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1434.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1443.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.66738 0.20021 0.

4.6711 10–3

eps 8.597 10–4 0.6679 0.2006 1.0181 10–3

–0.01

0.08 0.19 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_1452.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1462.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1472.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1481.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1492.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1502.svg
4.32523 10–3

1.79157 10–3 0.09774 0.56964 0.20021 –0.23595

4.3134 10–3

1.7867 10–3 0.09418 0.5652 0.1978 –0.2355

–0.28

–0.28 –3.64 –0.78 –1.20 0.19

10–2

10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2 5.10–2

F

../../../../_images/Object_1516.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1522.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1533.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1542.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1552.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1562.svg
3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 –0.33369

3.3029 10–3

3.3029 10–3 0.3357 0.3334 0.2007 –0.3336

–0.23

–0.23 0.60 –0.09 0.24 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

Remarques#

On note une variation (\(\text{< 0.23\%}\) ) des déplacements pour les points du plan \(z=0.005\) .

Modélisation E#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments D_PLAN (TRIA3 + QUAD4)

../../../../_images/1000595A00001C6C0000136E1FC7E94653094F79.svg

Conditions limites :

côté \(\mathrm{AB}\)

DDL_IMPO:

( Group_no:GRNM11

Dy: 0. )

côté \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:GRMA12

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:GRMA13

Pres: 1. )

Noms des nœuds :

\(A=\mathrm{N1}\)

\(B=\mathrm{N119}\)

\(C=\mathrm{N36}\)

\(D=\mathrm{N166}\)

\(E=\mathrm{N41}\)

\(F=\mathrm{N171}\)

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 171

Nombre de mailles et types : 200 TRIA350 QUAD4

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_1572.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1583.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1594.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1602.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1615.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1622.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 1.6685 0.20055 0.

7.3243 10–3

eps –0.8790 1.6241 0.2235 –0.0922

–0.21

12.10 –2.66 11.44 -

10–2

0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15

C

../../../../_images/Object_1634.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1642.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1652.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1662.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1672.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1682.svg
6.78109 10–3

2.80882 10–3 –0.60921 1.27771 0.20055 –0.94346

6.7670 10–3

2.8012 10–3 –0.5122 1.3302 0.2454 –0.8567

–0.21

–0.27 –15.92 4.11 22.36 –9.19

10–2

0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3

E

../../../../_images/Object_1692.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1701.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1713.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1722.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1732.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1742.svg
5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 –1.33425

5.1784 10–3

5.1784 10–3 0.4318 0.5315 0.2890 –1.2686

–0.22

–0.22 29.18 59.01 44.10 4.92

10–2

0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6

B

../../../../_images/Object_1754.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1761.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1771.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1781.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1792.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1801.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.66738 0.20021 0.

4.6641 10–3

eps –1.3198 10–2 0.6723 0.1977 –0.0219

–0.16

0.74 –1.25 -

10–2

0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

D

../../../../_images/Object_1813.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1821.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1831.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1841.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1853.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1861.svg
4.32523 10–3

1.79157 10–3 0.09774 0.56964 0.20021 –0.23595

4.3084 10–3

1.7854 10–3 0.07393 0.5728 0.1940 –0.2347

–0.39

–0.39 –24.36 0.55 –3.10 0.53

10–2

0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3

F

../../../../_images/Object_1872.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1881.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1893.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1902.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1916.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1924.svg
3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 –0.33369

3.2974 10–3

3.2974 10–3 0.2976 0.3245 0.1866 –0.3415

–0.39

–0.39 –10.81 –2.75 –6.80 –2.34

10–2

0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15

Remarques#

Le maillage est insuffisant pour des éléments linéaires.

Modélisation F#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments D_PLAN (QUAD8 + TRIA6)

../../../../_images/1000583A00002922000014E1F3BBD75A2BB4E5F3.svg

Conditions limites :

côté \(\mathrm{AB}\)

DDL_IMPO:

( Group_no:GRNM11

Dy: 0. )

côté \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:GRMA12

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:GRMA13

Pres: 1. )

Noms des nœuds :

\(A=\mathrm{N2}\)

\(B=\mathrm{N361}\)

\(C=\mathrm{N121}\)

\(D=\mathrm{N584}\)

\(E=\mathrm{N155}\)

\(F=\mathrm{N503}\)

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 591

Nombre de mailles et types : 200 TRIA650 QUAD8

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_1932.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1941.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1952.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1961.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1971.svg ../../../../_images/Object_1981.svg
  1. 7.3398 10–3 1.6685 –1. 0.20055 0.

  1. 7.3326 10–3 1.6669 –0.9959 0.20129 0.00332

  • –0.10 0.09 0.41 0.37 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

C

../../../../_images/Object_1991.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2002.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2011.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2021.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2031.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2042.svg
–2.80882 10–3

6.78109 10–3 1.27771 –0.60921 0.20055 0.94346

–2.8063 10–3

6.7745 10–3 1.27799 –0.60779 0.20106 0.94027

–0.09

–0.10 0.02 0.23 0.25 –0.34

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

E

../../../../_images/Object_2052.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2062.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2071.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2081.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2093.svg ../../../../_images/Object_21010.svg
–5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 1.33425

–5.1851 10–3

5.1851 10–3 0.33462 0.33403 0.20059 1.33117

–0.09

–0.09 0.11 –0.066 0.02 –0.23

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

B

../../../../_images/Object_2112.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2121.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2132.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2141.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2152.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2161.svg
  1. 4.6716 10–3 0.66738 0. 0.20021 0.

eps

4.6682 10–3 0.66758 0.00033 0.20037 –5.1132 10–4

  • –0.07 0.03 - 0.08 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_2171.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2181.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2192.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2201.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2213.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2221.svg
–1.79157 10–3

4.32523 10–3 0.56964 0.09774 0.20021 0.23595

–1.7865 10–3

4.3129 10–3 0.56962 0.09805 0.200298 0.23623

–0.28

–0.28 –0.003 0.32 0.044 0.12

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

F

../../../../_images/Object_2231.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2241.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2251.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2261.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2271.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2281.svg
–3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 0.33369

–3.3009 10–3

3.3009 10–3 0.33371 0.33366 0.20021 0.33392

–0.29

–0.29 0.006 –0.009 0. 0.069

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

Modélisation G#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

D_PLAN (QUAD9)

../../../../_images/1000340A00001C1D000013040783CFDD22A26E3D.svg

Conditions limites :

côté \(\mathrm{AB}\)

DDL_IMPO:

( Group_no:GRNM11

Dy: 0. )

côté \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:GRMA12

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:GRMA13

Pres: 1. )

Noms des nœuds :

\(A=\mathrm{N1}\)

\(B=\mathrm{N347}\)

\(C=\mathrm{N21}\)

\(D=\mathrm{N432}\)

\(E=\mathrm{N39}\)

\(F=\mathrm{N229}\)

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 441

Nombre de mailles et types : 100 QUAD9

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_2291.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2302.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2315.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2321.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2331.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2341.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 1.6685 0.20055 0.

7.3329 10–3

eps –0.9968 1.6655 0.20059 –2.97 10–4

–0.09

0.32 –0.18 0.02 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

C

../../../../_images/Object_2351.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2361.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2372.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2381.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2391.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2401.svg
6.78109 10–3

2.80882 10–3 –0.60921 1.27771 0.20055 –0.94346

6.7747 10–3

2.8062 10–3 –0.60695 1.27563 0.20060 –0.94128

–0.09

–0.09 0.37 –0.16 0.02 –0.23

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

E

../../../../_images/Object_2415.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2421.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2431.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2441.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2451.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2461.svg
5.19002 10–3

5.19002 10–3 0.33425 0.33425 0.20055 –1.33425

5.1851 10–3

5.1851 10–3 0.33403 0.33463 0.20059 –1.33117

–0.09

–0.09 –0.06 0.11 0.02 0.23

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

B

../../../../_images/Object_2471.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2481.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2491.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2501.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2515.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2521.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.66738 0.20021 0.

4.6682 10–3

eps –2.394 10–3 0.66759 0.200207 –2.65 10–5

–0.07

0.03 –0.001 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_2531.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2541.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2551.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2561.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2571.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2581.svg
4.32523 10–3

1.79157 10–3 0.09774 0.56964 0.20021 –0.23595

4.3128 10–3

1.7864 10–3 0.09756 0.56979 0.200206 –0.23611

–0.29

–0.29 –0.18 0.02 –0.002 –0.07

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

F

../../../../_images/Object_2591.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2602.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2614.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2622.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2631.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2642.svg
3.31039 10–3

3.31039 10–3 0.33369 0.33369 0.20021 –0.33369

3.3009 10–3

3.3009 10–3 0.33366 0.33371 0.20021 –0.33392

–0.29

–0.29 –0.009 0.006 0. –0.07

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

Modélisation H#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments axis (TRIA3 + QUAD4)

../../../../_images/1000368C00002DC900000D3BD1104C29DD008979.svg

Conditions limites :

côté \(\mathrm{AB}\)

DDL_IMPO:

( Group_no:GRNM11

Dy: 0. )

côté \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:GRMA12

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:GRMA13

Pres: 1. )

Noms des nœuds :

\(A=\mathrm{N111}\)

\(B=\mathrm{N1}\)

\(C=\mathrm{N112}\)

\(D=\mathrm{N3}\)

\(E=\mathrm{N113}\)

\(F=\mathrm{N4}\)

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 113

Nombre de mailles et types : 40 QUAD480 TRIA3

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_2651.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2662.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2671.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2681.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2691.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2701.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3390 10–3

eps –0.9430 0.2248 1.6923 eps

–0.01

–5.72 12.19 1.46 -

10–2

0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

C

../../../../_images/Object_2713.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2722.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2731.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2741.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2751.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2762.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3390 10–3

eps –0.9430 0.2248 1.6923 eps

–0.01

–5.72 12.19 1.46 -

10–2

0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

E

../../../../_images/Object_2771.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2781.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2791.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2801.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2811.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2821.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3390 10–3

0. –0.9430 0.2248 1.6923 eps

–0.01

–5.72 12.19 1.46 -

10–2

0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

B

../../../../_images/Object_2831.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2841.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2851.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2861.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2872.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2881.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6713 10–3

eps –0.0110 0.1954 0.6625 –0.0011

–0.01

–2.35 –0.72 -

10–2

0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

D

../../../../_images/Object_2891.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2901.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2912.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2921.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2931.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2941.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6713 10–3

eps –0.0110 0.1954 0.6625 eps

–0.01

–2.35 –0.72 -

10–2

0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

F

../../../../_images/Object_2951.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2962.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2971.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2981.svg ../../../../_images/Object_2991.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3001.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6713 10–3

eps –0.0110 0.1954 0.6625 +0.0011

–0.01

–2.35 –0.72 -

10–2

0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

Modélisation I#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments axis (TRIA6 + QUAD8)

../../../../_images/100020FC00002A4500000BC806B810DAD76F771A.svg

Conditions limites :

côté \(\mathrm{AB}\)

DDL_IMPO:

( Group_no:GRNM11

Dy: 0. )

côté \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:GRMA12

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:GRMA13

Pres: 1. )

Noms des nœuds :

\(A=\mathrm{N8}\)

\(B=\mathrm{N174}\)

\(C=\mathrm{N5}\)

\(D=\mathrm{N170}\)

\(E=\mathrm{N3}\)

\(F=\mathrm{N159}\)

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 175

Nombre de mailles et types : 20 QUAD840 TRIA6

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_3014.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3021.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3031.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3042.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3051.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3063.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3397 10–3

eps –0.9984 0.20055 1.669 eps

–0.00

–0.16 - –0.57 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

C

../../../../_images/Object_3071.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3081.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3091.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3101.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3113.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3121.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3397 10–3

eps –0.9984 0.20055 1.669 eps

–0.00

–0.16 - –0.57 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

E

../../../../_images/Object_3131.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3142.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3152.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3161.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3171.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3181.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3397 10–3

eps –0.9984 0.20055 1.669 eps

–0.00

–0.16 - –0.57 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

B

../../../../_images/Object_3191.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3201.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3211.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3221.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3231.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3241.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6716 10–3

eps 3.8 10–4 0.2002 0.66716 10–5

0.00

–0.03 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_3251.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3261.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3271.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3281.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3291.svg ../../../../_images/Object_330.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6716 10–3

eps 3.8 10–4 0.2002 0.66716 eps

0.00

–0.03 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

F

../../../../_images/Object_3311.svg ../../../../_images/Object_332.svg ../../../../_images/Object_333.svg ../../../../_images/Object_334.svg ../../../../_images/Object_335.svg ../../../../_images/Object_336.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6716 10–3

eps 3.8 10–4 0.2002 0.66716 10–5

0.00

–0.03 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

Modélisation J#

Caractéristiques de la modélisation#

Eléments axis (QUAD9)

../../../../_images/10001E5C00002E3300000C81479CA99E7D6C950D.svg

Conditions limites :

côté \(\mathrm{AB}\)

DDL_IMPO:

( Group_no:GRNM11

Dy: 0. )

côté \(\mathrm{EF}\)

FACE_IMPO:

( Group_ma:GRMA12

Dnor: 0. )

pression sur \(\mathrm{AE}\)

PRES_REP:

( Group_ma:GRMA13

Pres: 1. )

Noms des nœuds :

\(A=\mathrm{N196}\)

\(B=\mathrm{N1}\)

\(C=\mathrm{N200}\)

\(D=\mathrm{N5}\)

\(E=\mathrm{N202}\)

\(F=\mathrm{N7}\)

Caractéristiques du maillage#

Nombre de noeuds: 205

Nombre de mailles et types : 40 QUAD9

Grandeurs testées et résultats#

Localisation

Grandeurs

Référence

Aster

% différence

tolérance

A

../../../../_images/Object_337.svg ../../../../_images/Object_338.svg ../../../../_images/Object_339.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3401.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3411.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3421.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3397 10–3

eps –0.9984 0.2005 1.667

eps

–0.00

+0.16 - –0.57 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

C

../../../../_images/Object_343.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3441.svg ../../../../_images/Object_345.svg ../../../../_images/Object_346.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3471.svg ../../../../_images/Object_348.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3397 10–3

eps –0.9984 0.2005 1.667 eps

–0.00

+0.16 - –0.57 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

E

../../../../_images/Object_349.svg ../../../../_images/Object_350.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3511.svg ../../../../_images/Object_352.svg ../../../../_images/Object_353.svg ../../../../_images/Object_354.svg
7.3398 10–3

0. –1. 0.20055 1.6685 0.

7.3397 10–3

eps –0.9984 0.2005 1.667 eps

–0.00

+0.16 - –0.57 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

B

../../../../_images/Object_355.svg ../../../../_images/Object_356.svg ../../../../_images/Object_357.svg ../../../../_images/Object_358.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3591.svg ../../../../_images/Object_360.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6716 10–3

eps 1.1 10–4 0.20021 0.66727 eps

0.00

–0.04 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

D

../../../../_images/Object_3611.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3621.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3631.svg ../../../../_images/Object_364.svg ../../../../_images/Object_365.svg ../../../../_images/Object_366.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6716 10–3

eps 1.1 10–4 0.20021 0.66727 eps

0.00

–0.04 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

F

../../../../_images/Object_367.svg ../../../../_images/Object_368.svg ../../../../_images/Object_369.svg ../../../../_images/Object_370.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3711.svg ../../../../_images/Object_3721.svg
4.6716 10–3

0. 0. 0.20021 0.66738 0.

4.6716 10–3

eps 1.1 10–4 0.20021 0.66727 eps

0.00

0.02 –0.04 -

10–2

10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2 10–2

Synthèse des résultats#

Récapitulatif

des erreurs

3

D

D_PLAN

Axis

max en %

mod A

mod B

mod C

mod D

mod E

mod F

mod G

mod H

mod I

mod J

Déplacements

A,C,E B,D,F

–0.27 –0.39

–0.10 –0.02

–0.10 –0.68

0.17 –0.28

–0.27 –0.39

–0.10 –0.29

–0.09 –0.29

–0.01 –0.01

0.00 0.00

–0.00 –0.00

Contraintes

../../../../_images/Object_3731.svg
A,C,E

B,D,F

29.23

–24.39

0.10

0.02

16.92

–15.69

–9.20

–3.64

29.18

–24.36

0.11

0.03

0.37

–0.18

5.72
0.27
0.27

Contraintes

../../../../_images/Object_3741.svg
A,C,E

B,D,F

59.04

2.75

0.41

0.30

47.19

1.97

12.67

–0.78

59.01

–2.75

0.41

0.32

–0.18

0.03

12.19

–2.35

0.09

0.09

0.09

0.02

Contraintes

../../../../_images/Object_3751.svg
A,C,E

B,D,F

44.50

–6.80

0.37

0.04

21.51

–4.05

4.11

–1.20

44.10

–6.80

0.37

0.08

0.02

–0.001

1.46

–0.72

0.57

0.03

0.57

0.04

Contraintes

../../../../_images/Object_376.svg
A,C,E

B,D,F

9.20

–2.34

0.34

0.12

3.30

–7.84

–0.24

0.19

–9.19

–2.34

–0.34

0.12

0.23

–0.07

  • Les maillages pour les éléments d’ordre 1 ne sont pas assez fins.

  • Les résultats sont plus précis avec des éléments d’ordre 2.

  • Le problème est plus adapté à une modélisation axisymétrique (H, I, J) -> résultats meilleurs.

  • Les résultats des éléments \(\mathrm{3D}\) et des éléments plans ayant des espaces d’interpolation en correspondance sont identiques.

  • Les résultats des éléments axisymétriques QUAD8 et QUAD9 sont identiques.